A Local Guide to Pizza Restaurants in Monmouth County NJ
Pizza is woven into daily life in Monmouth County NJ, from Friday night takeout and post-practice family dinners to Shore-town evenings, downtown date nights, and easy stops along Route 9. This curated guide brings together pizza restaurants across Monmouth County, with options that fit beach days, errands, commuter routines, and casual nights close to home.
Shore-Town and Boardwalk-Friendly Pizza
Talula’s
In downtown Asbury Park, Talula’s brings a creative, ingredient-driven approach to pizza on Cookman Avenue. It works well for a night that starts with dinner and continues with a walk through the downtown arts and music district, making it a natural fit for anyone looking for pizza near the Jersey Shore with a more polished, sit-down feel. The restaurant’s official menu highlights naturally leavened sourdough pizza along with seasonal, vegetable-forward, and vegan-friendly choices that readers should confirm before visiting.
Pete & Elda’s / Carmen’s Pizzeria
Pete & Elda’s / Carmen’s Pizzeria in Neptune City is closely tied to the Shore-area pizza conversation, especially for thin-crust pies and casual group dinners. Located at 96 Woodland Avenue, it is convenient for readers coming from Bradley Beach, Avon-by-the-Sea, Neptune, and surrounding coastal communities. For families, friend groups, and anyone planning a relaxed pizza night near the Shore, it remains a familiar local name to know.
Vic’s Italian Restaurant
Vic’s Italian Restaurant at 60 Main Street in Bradley Beach is a long-running Shore-town dining stop with classic thin-crust pizza on its official ordering menu. Its Main Street location makes it easy to pair pizza with a Bradley Beach evening, whether that means a casual dinner before heading home or a simple takeout plan after time near the water. Readers should check the restaurant directly for current menu details before going.
Piazza on the Pier
Piazza on the Pier brings pizza into the Pier Village setting in Long Branch, making it a convenient choice for readers who want dining close to the boardwalk, beach, hotels, and oceanfront activity. The official menu includes pizza pies, and the location naturally fits a Long Branch day that moves between the beach, shopping, walking, and dinner. For visitors and locals alike, it offers a pizza option in one of Monmouth County’s most recognizable Shore districts.
Nunzio’s Pizzeria
Nunzio’s Pizzeria in Long Branch, located at 230 Westwood Avenue, is another Shore-area option for readers looking beyond the boardwalk corridor. Its official web presence includes direct ordering and a dinner menu, making it practical for takeout-focused nights in Long Branch, West Long Branch, and nearby coastal neighborhoods. For local routines, it fits the easy “bring pizza home” side of Monmouth County dining.
Downtown, Village, and Neighborhood Pizza
Federici’s Family Restaurant
Federici’s Family Restaurant at 14 East Main Street in Freehold brings pizza into the heart of downtown Freehold. Its official menu references its thin-crust pizza, and the location places it close to Main Street’s walkable restaurants, shops, and courthouse-area activity. It is a natural fit for readers looking for pizza in Freehold NJ before or after a downtown event, errands, or a casual night out.
Gianni’s Pizzeria
Gianni’s Pizzeria is useful for readers looking for pizza across several Monmouth County communities, with official location references for Red Bank, Little Silver, Colts Neck, and Monmouth Beach. That footprint makes it especially convenient for everyday routines: a quick dinner near the Navesink, takeout on the way home from activities, or pizza night near commuter-friendly corridors. It is a practical local option for readers comparing pizza restaurants in Monmouth County NJ by town.
Zoni’s Brooklyn Brick
Zoni’s Brooklyn Brick sits along the Route 35 Red Bank/Middletown corridor and focuses on coal-fired pizza, according to its official website. Its location makes it useful for readers moving between Middletown, Red Bank, Fair Haven, and the surrounding bayshore area. For a casual dinner after errands, youth sports, or a Route 35 commute, it offers a coal-fired option without leaving northern Monmouth.
Sally Boy's
Located at the corner of Broad Street in downtown Red Bank, Sally Boy's brings a fresh take on neighborhood pizza with New York-style pies, Italian specialties, and a lively, modern atmosphere. The restaurant focuses on premium ingredients, carefully crafted dough, and classic recipes with contemporary flair, making it a great stop for everything from a quick slice to a casual dinner with friends. Whether you're exploring downtown or looking for your next pizza night destination, Sally Boy's has quickly become a standout addition to Red Bank's dining scene.
Route 9 and Western Monmouth Pizza
Coal Fired Pizza
Coal Fired Pizza in Manalapan sits on Route 9, making it especially convenient for western Monmouth residents and commuters. The official website describes a coal-burning hearth and pizza cooked with high heat, giving Route 9 diners a coal-fired option without heading east toward the Shore. It is a useful choice for readers searching for pizza near Route 9 in Monmouth County.
Meli’s Thin & Crispy Pizza Co.
Meli’s Thin & Crispy Pizza Co. is located at 280 US-9 in the Marlboro/Morganville corridor. Its official website presents the restaurant around thin and crispy pizza, which fits readers who prefer a lighter, crisp style for casual dinners or takeout. The Route 9 setting makes it easy to work into errands, commuting, and weeknight routines across Marlboro, Morganville, Manalapan, and nearby western Monmouth neighborhoods.
Before You Go
This guide is curated, not ranked. It is designed to give readers a useful cross-section of pizza restaurants in Monmouth County NJ, including Shore-town options, downtown choices, coal-fired pizza, thin-crust spots, and Route 9 conveniences. Restaurant menus, ordering options, reservations, and availability can change, so confirm details directly with each restaurant before planning your visit.
Share Your Favorite
Have a favorite pizza spot in Monmouth County that belongs on the radar? Share the restaurant, what you like to order, and what makes it part of your local routine.