Updated October 2024:
Craving pizza? Let’s start with the classics. Head to Vic’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria in Bradley Beach. Their thin-crust pies are cooked to perfection in a brick oven and are sure to satisfy any pizza lover’s cravings. If you’re in the mood for some hearty Italian fare, check out Pete & Elda’s Bar/Carmen’s Pizzeria in Neptune City. This local institution has been serving up some of the best thin-crust pizza in the area since 1955.
And if you’re looking for something a little more upscale, head over to Porta in Asbury Park or Strada in Atlantic Highlands. These trendy spots offers wood-fired pizzas, fresh pasta, and creative cocktails in a stylish setting.
Craving a mix of tradition and innovation? Head to Via Sposito for a delightful fusion of old-world Italian charm and modern culinary trends. Savor local seasonal dishes and indulge in their passion for creating unforgettable flavors.
Looking for a quick bite without sacrificing quality? Visit Mike’s Pizza and Catering. Their hand-tossed, thin-crust pizzas and freshly made sandwiches are part of their “Good Food Fast” promise, featuring signature San Marzano tomato sauce for a drool-worthy experience. For something truly unique, check out Esposito’s Pizza. Known for their sesame seed crust, this Manasquan and Matawan staple serves up some of the best Italian dishes around.
- Vic’s Pizza, Bradley Beach
- Sea Bright Pizza, Sea Bright
AGENT FAVE
“I love Sea Bright Pizza’s Grandma’s Pie. Fresh tomato, fresh garlic – nothing from a can or jar!”
–Patrice Carden
- Strada Pizza Bar, Atlantic Highlands
- Julio’s Pizza Co., Atlantic Highlands & Keansburg
AGENT FAVE
“Julio’s in Atlantic Highlands, excellent service and good pizza!”
–Jeannette Sieh
- Pete & Elda’s, Neptune City
- Porta, Asbury Park,
- Mikes Pizza and Catering, Parlin
- Esposito’s Pizza, Red Bank
- The Brothers Italian Cuisine, Red Bank
- Denino’s Pizza Place, Aberdeen
- Via Sposito, Old Bridge
Back to Ultimate Foodie Guide.